Hunters Guide

Canada · bird identification

Upland Bird Identification

Name an upland bird by where it flushed and how it went, then confirm with plumage. Habitat plus flush behaviour separates almost every species on this page, and you get both of those for free in the first second.

An aspen and alder thicket in autumn, golden leaves carpeting the forest floor and dappled light coming through bare branches.

Which is lucky, because a flush gives you about a second and a half. Nobody reads eye combs in that window. You read cover type, size against the cover, the noise, and the line the bird takes.

So here are the five grouse, sorted by the two things you get for free.

SpeciesHabitatSizeThe flushThe cue
Ruffed grouseAspen, poplar, birch, alder, young mixed forest41 to 48 cmExplosive, low, doglegs through coverCrest, neck ruff, dark band near the tail tip
Spruce grouseConifer and taiga forest, dense young pine38 to 43 cmReluctant, short, often up to a low branchNo crest, dark grey male, scarlet eye combs
Blue grouse, dusky and sootyMountain slope, subalpine forest, cutblock edge44 to 57 cmHeavy and noisy, often lands in a coniferLargest forest grouse, slate-grey male, grey tail band
Sharp-tailed grouseGrassland, brushy parkland, farmland edge42 to 47 cmCackling, rapid beats then long glidesShort pointed tail, white outer feathers, V-marked breast
PtarmiganAlpine, subalpine and tundra30 to 43 cmClose and low, usually several at onceFeathered feet, white wings year round, white in winter

Ruffed grouse or spruce grouse

A ruffed grouse is a crested forest grouse of broad-leaved and mixed cover with a banded fan tail, while a spruce grouse is a darker, crestless bird of conifer forest, and behaviour separates them faster than plumage does.

Start with the flush. Hinterland Who's Who describes the ruffed grouse by "the explosive burst with which it takes flight", and that is what it feels like: a thunderclap of wings under your feet, a hard dogleg around a trunk, gone.

The spruce grouse does the opposite. It sits. It lets you walk within a few metres, and when it finally goes it often lands on a low conifer limb and stares. Which is how it got called the fool hen.

Then plumage. The ruffed grouse has a crest it can raise, dark neck ruff feathers, and a broad fan tail whose feathers are "banded black, brown, and buff with a wider black band near the tips". Spruce grouse males run "medium to blackish grey plumage with brilliant scarlet eye combs", no crest, much darker overall. Hens are browner and more cinnamon.

What does not separate them is size. Ruffed runs about 41 to 48 cm, spruce 38 to 43 cm, so the ranges overlap and a bird in the air gives you no ruler.

Naming a sharp-tailed grouse

A sharp-tailed grouse is a medium grouse of open grassland, brushy parkland and farmland edge, named for the short pointed tail that flashes white on the outer feathers as it flies away from you.

Habitat does most of the work. Flush a grouse out of grass and low shrub with a view to the horizon and you are not looking at a forest bird. Then the tail, whose feathers are "graduated with the center rectrices longest", giving that stubby point instead of a fan.

The flight confirms it. A burst of rapid beats, a long flat glide, repeated, usually with a chuckling cackle. In the hand, look at the breast. Buffy with brown V shapes, where every other grouse here is barred.

Is a blue grouse the same as a dusky grouse?

Blue grouse is the old name for a large dark mountain grouse now split into two species, the dusky grouse of the interior and the sooty grouse of the coast. Plenty of provincial material and plenty of hunters still say blue grouse for both.

It is the largest forest grouse at 44 to 57 cm. Males are "bluish to blackish grey with yellow to reddish eye combs"; hens are plain brownish grey and get taken for spruce grouse hens constantly. Coastal birds carry a wide grey band at the tail tip, interior birds a narrow band or none. Look for it on mountain slopes, subalpine timber and cutblock edges, often higher in autumn than you expect, and expect a heavy noisy flush that ends in a conifer.

Why a ptarmigan changes colour through the year

A ptarmigan is an alpine and tundra grouse that moults into white winter plumage for camouflage in snow, so the mottled brown bird you saw in September is a white bird in January.

Hinterland Who's Who states it flatly: "In winter, all ptarmigans of both sexes are basically white." They run three plumages a year rather than the usual two, so spring and fall leave a patchy half-white, half-barred stage that confuses people badly.

Two features never change. The feet: "All ptarmigans have feathered feet, unique among chickenlike birds". And the wings stay white in every season, so a grouse-shaped bird with white wings in August is a ptarmigan and nothing else.

Separating the three species is harder, and the tail is the only cue worth trusting. Provincial inventory material says of the white-tailed ptarmigan: "Only grouse with white rectrices". It is also the smallest North American grouse at 30 to 34 cm.

Willow and rock ptarmigan keep black tail feathers all year. A winter male rock ptarmigan adds a black stripe through the eye, which willow males lack. That is a male cue, and it is not present on every bird.

Hungarian partridge or hen pheasant

A Hungarian partridge, also called the gray partridge, is a small round grey-brown gamebird of grain country, and a hen pheasant is a much larger long-tailed bird of the same fields, so tail length and body size split them immediately.

The partridge runs 30 to 33 cm, with rusty orange on the face and throat, a dark horseshoe mark on the lower breast, and short rounded chestnut tail feathers that read as a rufous flash going away. It flushes as a covey, low and fast on whirring wings, and scatters. Sexing one in the field is not realistic; the provincial description says the sexes are "similar in appearance and difficult to distinguish in the field".

Pheasants are the opposite, easy to name and easy to sex. A rooster runs about 84 cm with a white neck ring, red face patch, iridescent bronze body and a very long pointed tail. A hen is about 53 cm and plainly mottled buff and brown, but she keeps that long pointed tail, which is what sets her apart from every grouse and partridge in the same cover.

Roosters usually cackle on the flush. Hens usually leave quietly.

Tom turkey or hen

A tom is an adult male wild turkey with a bare head that changes colour, black-tipped breast feathers and a beard on the chest, while a hen is smaller, duller and carries a dull grey head.

Both sexes have the "Head and neck nearly bare", but on a tom that bare skin is the giveaway: it flushes red, white and blue with his mood, and the caruncles and throat dewlap are heavy and fleshy. A hen keeps a smaller, duller blue-grey head with light feathering up the back of the neck.

Breast feathers are the cue that works in flat light at distance with no strutting going on. Tom tips are black, so he reads as a solid dark bird. Hen tips are buff or brown, so she reads lighter at the same range. The provincial description agrees: female colouration is "more rusty brown tipped with white", and hens "Often lack frontal tuft, lack spurs".

Now the caveat that catches people. Some hens grow beards. Not many, but often enough that a beard alone is not proof of a male, and a bearded hen still shows a grey head and pale-tipped breast feathers. So use three cues: head, breast tips, body bulk. Spurs are real, but you will not see them at any useful distance.

Drill it on paper before you drill it in the field. Our Ontario wildlife identification practice questions work bird cues in the same order, habitat and behaviour first.

Does upland identification matter beyond the exam?

Yes. Identification is what lets you account for the bird in your hand, because limits and rules are written species by species rather than for upland birds as a category.

We are not listing any of that here. It differs by province and by area, and it changes. Read the current regulations for your own jurisdiction every season, from the agency that publishes them. The part you can build ahead of time is the eye. For hares, coyotes and furbearers, the same cue-by-cue approach is in small game and furbearer identification.

Questions about identifying upland birds

Which grouse is the tame one that will not flush?

The spruce grouse, which is how it earned the nickname fool hen. It often sits tight while you walk past, and when it does move it frequently flies only as far as a low conifer branch and then watches you. A ruffed grouse in the same cover goes out hard and fast in a burst.

What is the quickest way to name a sharp-tailed grouse?

The tail and the ground under it. The tail is short, pointed and wedge-shaped, and the white outer feathers show as the bird goes away, off open grassland or brushy parkland rather than out of timber. The breast carries brown V-shaped markings instead of even barring.

Do ptarmigan look the same all year?

No. Ptarmigan carry three plumages a year and go essentially white in winter, both sexes, which is the whole point of the bird. Two things never change: the feet are feathered, unique among the grouse family, and the wings stay white in every season.

Can a hen turkey have a beard?

Yes, a small percentage of hens grow one, so a beard on its own does not confirm a male. Read the head and the breast feathers as well. A tom carries a bare head that flushes red, white and blue, and black-tipped breast feathers that make him look dark.

How do you tell a hen pheasant from a Hungarian partridge?

Size and tail length settle it instantly. A hen pheasant is a big bird with a long pointed tail streaming behind her. A Hungarian partridge is small and round with a short rusty tail, and it usually flushes as a covey that buzzes off low and scatters.

Study and identification material only. Nothing here is legal advice or a statement of any rule. Before you hunt, read the current regulations published for your own province or territory and work from those.